Updated on August 12th, 2026
To follow-up on my Reading Through Cookbooks post, I decided to make the Frozen Strawberry Pie from the Frozen Yogurt cookbook.
The recipe includes 2 parts, making the frozen yogurt and making the cookies. Once both parts are prepared, they are assembled with strawberries to turn it into a Frozen Strawberry Pie.
Frozen Strawberry Pie
6
servings5
hoursIngredients
- Frozen Natural Yogurt
500 grams natural yogurt
2 deciliters cream for whipping
80 grams sugar
- Sugar Cookies
1 egg
50 grams sugar
75 grams butter
200 grams flour
- Assembly
250 grams strawberries
Frozen yogurt from part 1
Cookies from part 2
Directions
- Frozen Natural Yogurt
- Whisk the yogurt and sugar with a hand mixer
- In a separate bowl, whisk the cream until it becomes light and fluffy like whipped cream and does not fall out of the bowl when you flip it over
- Add the whipped cream to the yogurt and whisk it until it is combined
- Place the yogurt in a sealed freezer-safe container and put it in the freezer for at least 4 hours
- Once every hour, take the yogurt out and stir it
- Sugar Cookies
- Whisk the egg and sugar together
- In a separate bowl whisk the butter
- Slowly add the butter and flour to the egg and sugar mixture
- Once the ingredients are combined, form the dough with your hands
- Roll out the dough then place it in the fridge for 30 minutes
- Take the dough out of the fridge
- Preheat the oven to 200° C
- Form the dough into desired shapes by either using a cookie cutter or hand cutting the dough
- Bake the cookies for 8 minutes until the edges are lightly browned and let the cookies cool
- Assembly
- Rinse the strawberries and cut into slices
- Place the cookies on a plate
- Top the cookies with the strawberry slices
- Add a scoop of the frozen yogurt on top of each cookie
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Frozen Strawberry Pie taste like?
The dessert tastes great! The cookies do taste a bit plain by themselves, but with the frozen yogurt and strawberries they are delicious. The frozen yogurt does have the natural flavor, which you may want to add toppings to if you are eating it by itself.
Can you add other toppings to the frozen yogurt?
Yes, besides strawberries you can easily add other toppings. Some toppings you can add are chocolate, Nutella, other fruit, granola, muesli, nuts like pistachios or peanuts, sprinkles, and even candy.
What freezer-safe container can you use?
I used a freezer-safe Tupperware container with a lid for the frozen yogurt. However, not all Tupperware is freezer-safe. If the container has a snowflake symbol on it, then you can use it in the freezer. You can also use a glass container, but again, you should check on the container if it is freezer-safe.
Why do you stir the yogurt every hour?
The yogurt is stirred every hour to avoid ice crystals from forming. Furthermore, stirring the frozen yogurt keeps it at an airy texture.
Can you use an ice cream machine to make the frozen yogurt?
Yes, you can! If you have an ice cream machine, for step 4 you can put the yogurt in the machine for 25 minutes instead of in the freezer.
What texture should the cookie dough have?
The dough should have a smooth texture and come together in one ball. If you find that the dough is too wet and sticky, you can add a little more flour.
Looks and sounds so good 🙂
Brianna | http://briannamarielifestyle.com/
It is! 😄
I’ve never made frozen yoghurt, but I think this is a great idea, especially for the summer when you want something cool and refreshing
It is! It’s also so easy to make & you only need 3 ingredients!
Yes ! The frozen yoghurt recipe is mine now ! 😋 Thank you so much for sharing 💕
Haha you’re welcome! I hope you enjoy it! 😊
Looks and sounds good. Snowflake symbol on Tupperware had forgotten about.
Thanks! It is delicious! 😄
I’m a huge frozen yogurt lover, so this post is going to come in handy one day soon!
Me too! It was fun making it myself for once 😊
I didn’t know this can be home made, I usually eat it in stores. I would definitely love to make it, it seems not too hard. xx
The frozen yogurt part is really easy to make especially since there are only 3 ingredients!
Well, I never knew how to make frozen yoghurt, now I do! It sounds pretty simple, which is great as I am a rubbish cook! Thanks for sharing xx
You’re welcome! It is really simple & you only need 3 ingredients 😄
This looks so yummy and easy to make! I guess i will be trying this recipe this weekend! Thanks for the inspo!
You’re welcome! It is so easy & delicious! I hope you like it! 😊
OOh this looks good and not too complex. I love frozen yogurt so think trying to make it would be so much fun x
It is really easy to make especially since there are only 3 ingredients & it was fun to make 😄
It’s a shame that the cookies were so plain! Maybe they would have been better with a bit of cocoa powder in them? Looks good anyways though!
I think it would be good if they were chocolaty since strawberries & chocolate go great together!
Cool! I’ve always wanted to make my own Ice cream! Would you use this recipe again?
For the frozen yogurt, yes I would! I like the natural flavor & I can eat it by itself or with toppings. I would use a different recipe for the cookies because like I said they tasted plain by themselves.